December Stocking Drops

OhmOhm Member Posts: 241 ✭✭✭
edited December 3 in General Discussion
After the long wait and initial hiccups with the gems. Here is what stockings are dropping

Bought 10 Fancy Stockings

S1 Collar of Taming 15 Betting Tickets
S2 Ivory Dice Vorpal Key Gem
S3 Propaganda Pamphlet Truesilver Kegs Gem
S4 Ivory figurine Truesilver Kegs
S5 Grease Armband of Celerity Gem
S6 Grease Magnifying Glass
S7 Token of Creator Vorpal Key Gem
S8 Propaganda Pamphlet Truesilver Axe Gem
S9 Arti Vial Botanical Guidebook
S10 Bookbinder's Trinket Vorpal Key Gem


Bought 5 Grand Stockings (guaranteed gems)

S1 Boomerang Token of Creator
S2 Orb of suppression Gloves of Harvesting
S3 feathered armband Propaganda Pamphlet
S4 Gem of Cloaking Bookbinder's trinket
S5 feathered armband Brooch of the Tempest

Overall, the grand ones are quite underwhelming for what you are paying. Seriously, the loot in them needs to be better than Token of the Creator and Brooch of the Tempest and bookbinder's trinket. You are paying quite a bit more for these compared to fancy ones to have garbage in them (roughly  $50/ stocking)
image
Zerin

Comments

  • ZerinZerin Member Posts: 67 ✭✭✭
    Don't whinge - I got 2x familiar from one of my stockings!
    Aodan
  • DimitriDimitri Somewhere coldMember Posts: 249 ✭✭✭
  • SarriusSarrius Member, Beta Testers Posts: 1,555 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited December 3
    If grand is underwhelming compared to fancy, this makes my decision on purchasing very easy.

    I'd like to know - are the loot tables distinctly different? Is there overlap? Are the tables actually the same and drop rates are fudged per stocking type? Need these questions answered before I can safely buy and.. honestly.. that kinda stuff should be in our announce posts. :/

    I'd like to know especially what the Extravagant loot table looks like and why it is so much more expensive. It needs to beat 10 fancy stockings in yield or it isn't as intelligent a purchase. Do extravagant stockings hold only artifacts? What's the deal there?

    EDIT: This entire issue could be avoided if we just got rid of the concept of 'dud' rolls. I'm giving this game my IRL cash - why are you going to make my gained value a gigantic Question Mark because you included a bunch of useless duds on the loot table that don't sell for anything? See: @Zerin and her 2x familiar roll.
  • SarriusSarrius Member, Beta Testers Posts: 1,555 ✭✭✭✭✭
    You open a fancy chocolate brown and white stocking and find a Brooch of the Tempest (33cr), a Cloak of
    Obfuscate (kept) and a multi-facet gem inside!

    You open a fancy chocolate brown and white stocking and find a caravan crop (50cr) and a gem of radiant
    offerings (66cr) inside!

    You open a fancy chocolate brown and white stocking and find a Monocle of Acuity (66cr) and a gem of
    radiant offerings (66cr) inside!

    You open a fancy chocolate brown and white stocking and find a Token of the Creator, a dragonskin
    quiver (50cr) and a multi-facet gem inside!

    You open a fancy chocolate brown and white stocking and find 15 gladiator betting tickets and a
    caravan crop (50cr) inside!

    You open a fancy chocolate brown and white stocking and find a multi-facet gem, an ebony figurine (kept)
    and wolverine's claws (66cr) inside!

    You open a fancy chocolate brown and white stocking and find a Cloak of Obfuscate (66cr) and a bookbinder's
    trinket inside!

    You open a fancy chocolate brown and white stocking and find a multi-facet gem, a translucent glass
    box (66cr) and a vorpal key (50cr) inside!

    You open a fancy chocolate brown and white stocking and find a lamiran amulet (66cr), a miniature schelkin
    and a tiny reindeer festooned with bells inside!

    You open a fancy chocolate brown and white stocking and find 15 gladiator betting tickets, a multi
    -facet gem and a vorpal key (50cr) inside!

    745?.. plus I ended up trading my bookbinder's trinket too, dunno how much that was worth. Plus 1 100cr artifact and a 1 150cr artifact. Have not sold my gems yet.
    Zerin
  • OhmOhm Member Posts: 241 ✭✭✭
    Here is my problem, grand ones should guarantee better outcomes. Because rolling low on a $50 stocking is much more devastating than rolling low on a $15 stocking. As is, the value of a grand one should be 3.33x better. At this point it doesn’t seem anywhere close to that. I want to trade my grand ones to fancy ones considering they had the gem issue and I feel that I’m not getting enough bang for my buck in the grand ones. These things should be monitored and adjusted. No way a 50 USD stocking should have familiars. that is just silly considering it’s not picking 3 times - just the same 2 times 
    image
  • ZerinZerin Member Posts: 67 ✭✭✭
    Honestly, I think Grand is good value if you want one of the mid-range artifacts off the loot table (I got Gem of Cloaking - I kept this-, Feathered Armlet and a Scorpion's Tail, + soulstone + 3 gems) - so 1100 credit value sans tradein, plus 100 per gem. Even after tradein it was still pretty good.

    Otherwise it does look like Fancy is the way to go. In fairness too, that familiar stocking also gave me a Gem of Cloaking so it balanced out. I just thought it was funny that familiars would be in there at all.
    Ohm
  • LynyssaLynyssa AustraliaMember Posts: 40 ✭✭
    I bought one grand one and got a ring of vitality, a gem, and an ivory figurine.
    Aodan tells you, "Yank me."
    Sarrius
  • WyllWyll Member Posts: 296 ✭✭✭
    This is what you get for nearly 3x the value of a grand stocking and it seems you get the same crap in an extravagant that you get in a grand. Sorry, I'm not buying more to get a bigger 'sample size' at $130 a pop.

    You open an extravagant chocolate brown and white stocking and find a Scorpion's Tail, a multi-facet gem and a wand of reflection inside!

    That tail is worth 400 credits before tradein, 300 after tradein. That wand is 200 before tradein and 132 after tradein.

    I got a total of 332 bound credits for $130. Complete rip off.

    I can spend $10 more and get 400 unbound credits for $140 off the website before the 30% bonus at the moment. I effectively paid 0.39 cents per credit acquired for this stocking.

    Every fancy stocking has pulled a 66 credit tradein item at least with a 50% chance for a gem. One extravagant stocking can get you 8(plus 1 bonus I am not counting) fancy stockings. That's a min of 528 tradein not including gems or the bonus stocking.

    I took one for the team since no one wanted to drop $130 to test out the extravagant, but wow was that underwhelming.
    You say, "Oh crap."
    You say, "My bottle is empty."
    Jeremy raises an eyebrow questioningly.
    Jeremy slaps you on the cheek.
    Zerin
  • OhmOhm Member Posts: 241 ✭✭✭
    Honestly, we are getting less for spending more. I would hope @Jeremy or the admin in general are more transparent about expected drop rates. For real money things, it feels like a rip off to get less for spending on higher items. Both grand and extravagant are fairly underwhelming.

    If I could, I’d open fancy ones instead of grand ones knowing the drop rates confirmed by Jeremy.
    image
    Wyll
  • GaltGalt Member, Beta Testers Posts: 152 ✭✭✭
    You open a fancy chocolate brown and white stocking and find a dagger of reincarnation and an Ivory Brooch inside!
    You open a fancy chocolate brown and white stocking and find a bucket of wheel grease, a multi-facet gem and wolverine's claws inside!
    You open a fancy chocolate brown and white stocking and find a Token of the Creator, a gangly golden cria, a multi-facet gem and an Anklet of
    Dashing inside!
    You open a fancy chocolate brown and white stocking and find a Token of the Creator, a multi-facet gem and a vialbelt of truesilver kegs inside!
    You open a fancy chocolate brown and white stocking and find a multi-facet gem, a translucent glass box and an Anklet of Dashing inside!

    I'm happy. :hushed:
    DreacorSarriusOhmAkraine
  • OzreasOzreas Member, Beta Testers Posts: 200 ✭✭✭
    - Fancy stockings have about a 50% chance for a bonus gem.

    You open a fancy green and silver stocking and find a caravan crop and an ivory figurine inside!

    You open a fancy green and silver stocking and find a Propaganda Pamphlet and a steel mallet inside!

    You open a fancy green and silver stocking and find 5 credits, a botanical guidebook and a gangly golden cria inside!

    You open a fancy green and silver stocking and find a Monocle of Acuity and a dagger of reincarnation inside!

    You open a fancy green and silver stocking and find 20 credits and a vialbelt of truesilver kegs inside!

     :'( 
  • ZerinZerin Member Posts: 67 ✭✭✭
    Are fancy stockings still dropping them...? I also bought 3 (4? maybe) yesterday and today and got no gems from them. 
  • WyllWyll Member Posts: 296 ✭✭✭
    It is entirely possible to roll the butt half of 50% too. Because it is 50% each time with no memory of the last roll.
    You say, "Oh crap."
    You say, "My bottle is empty."
    Jeremy raises an eyebrow questioningly.
    Jeremy slaps you on the cheek.
    Pepehi
  • OystirOystir Member Posts: 414 ✭✭✭
    edited December 11
    I understand that the prizes this time around are *much* more valuable than they were last time there was a stocking event.

    I also understand that giving away free things and upping the value of prizes/lowering the cost of good stockings is all a hit to Imperian's bottom line.

    But I do lament the changes to the promotion since last year. Specifically the removal of the 1 free stocking for everyone, and substituting stockings for every X credits you buy for the 30% credit sale.

    I'm not a gambler by any means - I prefer finite value for my money - so it would just be fun to be able to participate in opening stockings without having to specifically buy a chance with real money. 
     You say, "This is much harder than just being a normal person."
    Aodan
  • EoghanEoghan Member, Immortal Posts: 815 mod
    Oystir said:
    But I do lament the changes to the promotion since last year. Specifically the removal of the 1 free stocking for everyone 
    Don't speak too soon!
    Like what we're doing? Why not take a second to vote? Vote for Imperian at http://www.imperian.com/vote
    OystirDreacorAodanSarrius
  • JustusJustus Member Posts: 36 ✭✭✭
    edited December 11
    My memory of older promotions were that in accompaniment of credit purchases, you'd get gift bags or stockings as an aside. Everything now seems to just be glorified gambling. Which is endemic within the gaming industry as a whole, as opposed to a problem that's related to IRE.

    The only people to blame, however, is ourselves. If we didn't buy them, it would be clear that they should try a different tact. Unfortunately, as we elect to spend our money on a % chance of a better prize than the worth of our purchase, this is the predicament one finds oneself in. 

    A touch of self refectlion is necessary here. One shouldn't choose to gamble and then complain about the outcome. 

    I came back after not having played since 2012. The single biggest overwhelming change was the veritable stream of promotional items et al which all seemed to have been borne out of this incessantly popular gambling mechanic. The players created the monster - and what business wouldn't cater to the demands of the player base. 
    AodanRokas
  • DimitriDimitri Somewhere coldMember Posts: 249 ✭✭✭
    Justus said:
    My memory of older promotions were that in accompaniment of credit purchases, you'd get gift bags or stockings as an aside. Everything now seems to just be glorified gambling. Which is endemic within the gaming industry as a whole, as opposed to a problem that's related to IRE.

    The only people to blame, however, is ourselves. If we didn't buy them, it would be clear that they should try a different tact. Unfortunately, as we elect to spend our money on a % chance of a better prize than the worth of our purchase, this is the predicament one finds oneself in. 

    A touch of self refectlion is necessary here. One shouldn't choose to gamble and then complain about the outcome. 

    I came back after not having played since 2012. The single biggest overwhelming change was the veritable stream of promotional items et al which all seemed to have been borne out of this incessantly popular gambling mechanic. The players created the monster - and what business wouldn't cater to the demands of the player base. 

Sign In or Register to comment.